Naked and humiliated woman cries out in rage and anguish as an
older woman comforts her while a mob surround them during an
anti-Jewish pogrom. Lvov, July.1st, 1941
The
Soviet Union occupied Lvov in September 1939, according to secret
provisions of the German-Soviet Pact. Germany invaded the Soviet Union
on June 22, 1941, occupying Lvov within a week.
The
Germans claimed that the city's Jewish population had supported the
Soviets. Ukrainian mobs went on a rampage against Jews. They stripped
and beat Jewish women and men in the streets of Lvov. Ukrainian
partisans supported by German authorities killed about 4,000 Jews in
Lvov during this pogrom. US forces discovered this 8mm footage in SS
barracks in Augsberg, Germany, after the war.
Lwów
(modern: Lviv) was a multicultural city just before World War II, with a
population of 312,231. It had been part of the Second Polish Republic
from 1918 to 1939. The city's 157,490 ethnic Poles constituted just over
50 per cent, with Jews at 32 per cent (99,595) and Ukrainians at 16 per
cent (49,747).
On 28 September 1939, after the joint Soviet-German invasion,
the USSR and Germany signed the German–Soviet Frontier Treaty, which
assigned about 200,000 km2 (77,000 sq mi) of Polish territory inhabited
by 13.5 million people of all nationalities to the Soviet Union. Lviv
was then annexed to the Soviet Union.
According
to Soviet Secret Police (NKVD) records, nearly 9,000 prisoners were
murdered in the Ukrainian SSR in the NKVD prisoner massacres, after the
German invasion of the Soviet Union began on 22 June 1941.
Due
to the confusion during the rapid Soviet retreat and incomplete
records, the NKVD number is most likely an undercounting. According to
estimates by contemporary historians, the number of victims in Western
Ukraine was probably between 10,000 and 40,000.[8] By ethnicity,
Ukrainians comprised roughly 70 per cent of victims, with Poles at 20
per cent.
According to scholar Jeffrey
Kopstein, the Polish population "awaited the German arrival with a
mixture of fear and hope", having resented their loss of control of the
city under Soviet occupation. The Ukrainian minority had been "nominal
owners" of the city since 1939 but "the Ukrainian nationalst
intelligentsia... found Soviet rule a huge disappointment, an insult to
their hopes for a truly independent Ukraine.
They
hoped for German liberation and German help in recapturing the city as
the capital of their own nation-building project." Prior to the German
invasion of the Soviet Union, some Ukrainian nationalists, specifically
in the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN), had been working
with the Germans.
As the historian John-Paul Himka writes, the OUN
at this point was a divided organization: in Lviv, the splinter faction
loyal to Stepan Bandera, known as OUN-B, led locally by Yaroslav
Stetsko, "a prominent lieutenant of Bandera’s as well as an extreme
anti-Semite", took over the nationalist movement. In 1939, Stetsko
published an article in which he claimed that Jews were "nomads and
parasites", a nation of "swindlers" and "egotists" whose aim was to
"corrupt the heroic culture of warrior nations". Stetsko also railed
against the supposed conspiracy between Jewish capitalists and Jewish
Communists. The OUN-B nationally called Jews props of the Bolsheviks,
but explicitly called on Ukrainians to eschew anti-Jewish pogroms (seen
as a diversion from targeting the real enemy, Moscow) at its Second
Great Congress, held in Kraków in April 1941.
Nonetheless,
the local OUN-B's preparations for the anticipated German invasion
included May 1941 instructions for ethnic cleansing to its planned
militia units: “At a time of chaos and confusion it is permissible to
liquidate undesirable Polish, Russian, and Jewish activists, especially
supporters". "Russians, Poles, Jews" were hostile to the Ukrainian
nation and were to be "destroyed in battle".
supported Communism and the Soviet Union, a
perception shaped by prevalent antisemitism among Ukrainian and Polish
communities, who had little meaningful interaction with Jewish
neighbours and refugees. Kiebuzinski and Motyl also emphasise the role
of Nazi propaganda in instigating the violence.
Jeffrey
Kopstein shows that the Germans eagerly facilitated anti-Jewish
violence by locals, but that such violence occurred in places where they
were not present, so their presence in Lvov facilitated it and made it
more brutal, but was not the sufficient or necessary cause. He notes
that resentment towards Soviet occupation was clearly a factor, but that
known ethnic Ukrainian Soviet collaborators were spared. The role of
Ukrainian nationalists was therefore significant, but "any account [of
the pogroms] as primarily an OUN operation misses something important.
The OUN was a small organization spread thinly on the ground.
They
tried to recruit locals, but adherence was spotty and opportunistic...
excessive focus on their role risks overlooking an essential feature...:
the participation of broad segments of the Ukrainian population in the
pogrom's mass, carnivalesque character." Kopstein also emphasises the
role of Zionism as a powerful current among Lvov Jews (in contrast to
parts of western Ukraine where Zionist support was low or Communist
support was high, which tended to have fewer pogroms) that meant it was
seen as a threat by both Polish and Ukrainian nationalists.

No comments:
Post a Comment